What happens when your healthcare provider leaves your Advantage Plan’s network?

Your doctor has left the network. Good bye!

I thought I knew the answer to this question, and I thought the answer relied simply on whether your plan included coverage for out-of-network services, like this:

  • If the plan is an HMO with no out-of-network coverage, then you pay the full cost if you continue to use that provider. You’ll need to find a new provider who is in-network.
  • If your plan is a PPO, then you can continue to see the provider because PPOs include out-of-network coverage. But in most plans, you pay a greater portion of the charges when you go out-of-network.

That answer isn’t totally wrong, but it’s incomplete. I learned this as I followed two situations that arose during the fall open enrollment period for State of Illinois retirees enrolled in the TRAIL Medicare Advantage plan operated by AETNA. On the surface, it seemed that the two situations were the same. But the impacts on plan participants were totally different.

TRAIL is a PPO Plan. More specifically, it is a PPO ESA (extended service area) plan, meaning that participants not only have out-of-network coverage, their cost is the same whether the provider they see is in- or out-of-network.

The first situation of a provider leaving the network was in the Chicago area. Endeavor announced that they would no longer be in network and that you might want to choose a new Advantage Plan, or switch to Traditional Medicare (yeah, but the last section of this post about the issues with that idea). But their announcement further explained that participants in TRAIL or any other Aetna PPO ESA plan would not be impacted!

So far, so good:  that matched with my original thoughts about how this works.

But then I started reading about the second situation, the exit of Barnes Jewish Hospital (BJC) from the exact same plan, TRAIL Medicare Advantage plan operated by AETNA .But this story was completely different.

Here’s what was different between the two situations: AETNA said TRAIL members along with any other PPO ESA plan members were simply not affected by Endeavor leaving the network.

But both AETNA and BJC were clear that TRAIL members could no longer be seen by BJC providers. You wouldn’t just pay more; you would not be seen by BJC at all and would be referred by BJC to another provider. A fact sheet prepared by Illinois Central Management Services led with the statement that “BJC HealthCare is terminating its Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug (MAPD) contract effective January 1, 2027.”  It further stated, “BJC HealthCare has elected not to see ESA plan members if they do not meet the medical necessity guidelines for continuation of care.”

BJCs website confirmed that information, stating “Generally, patients with out-of-network coverage will be redirected by BJC to a provider outside BJC that is in-network for the patient.” (BJC.org)  They say “generally” because there are situations where they are legally required to provide “continuity of care” or where there is no other provider for that care in that geographic region. Authorization from AETNA or Anthem would be required in those situations.

It was at this point that I began to realize the significance of a phrase that appeared in the notice that AETNA sent to participants affected by Endeavor leaving the network. For Advantage plans that included out-of-network coverage, it said, “You can keep using this hospital. That’s because you can use any hospital eligible for Medicare payment and willing to accept your plan. Just make sure they’ll accept your plan and bill us directly [emphasis added].”

It turns out, that last sentence was perhaps the most important sentence in the entire notice. That’s what makes the Endeavor and BJC situations so different.

What’s a person to do?

When you’re affected by a change like this, you have several options:

  • If your plan includes out-of-network coverage and the provider will still see you, you may need to do nothing. However, recognize that changes like this can happen at any time. And with BJC the problem has just been kicked down the road for another year.
  • You could switch to a different Advantage plan where your provider is in-network.
  • You could switch back to Original Medicare. But here you may run into problems. Most people on Original Medicare also purchase a Part D prescription plan and a Medicare Supplement plan. Part D is easy – you can always choose a drug plan during the annual open enrollment period which ends on Dec. 7. The problem comes when you try to purchase a Medicare Supplement Plan to cover your out-of-pocket costs, which are unlimited without a Supplement plan. You only have one true open enrollment for a Medicare Supplement Plan, when you have Guaranteed Issue Rights and can purchase any plan without medical underwriting. That is the six months starting with the first month that you are 65 and have Medicare Part B. After that, there are limited circumstances where you can purchase a plan without the insurance company looking at your medical history, deciding whether to offer you a policy, which one, or at what price. For a short discussion of all those situations, see my blog post on Medicare Enrollment Periods. Scroll down to the last section, Medigap/Medicare Supplement Plans Have Different Rules. But keep reading this post to learn more about the Special Enrollment Period that could be relevant when a provider leaves your network.

Does this change qualify you for a Special Enrollment Period for a Medicare Supplement Plan?

There is a particular category of Special Enrollment Period for Medicare Supplement Plans that I thought might apply here. It’s when “Your plan’s network has changed significantly.” That’s the wording in the Choosing A Medigap Policy book, p. 18 and on the Medicare.gov page about purchasing a Supplement (aka Medigap) plan. Scroll down to, What if I miss my Medigap Open Enrollment Period and click on link that says What are guaranteed rights? 🛈.

{screenshot}

Usually, the decision about whether this situation qualifies for a Special Enrollment Period would be made before the notice goes out about the provider leaving the network.

But even the exit of BJC apparently didn’t meet the standard to provide a Special Enrollment Period for Supplement plans. The Illinois CMS fact sheet has a section titled, “Are there adequate providers to see me” if I need to switch (to a different healthcare provider? The answer begins, “Based upon Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (Federal CMS) guidelines, there is no network adequacy concern.” I pretty sure that means no, this does not give you a Special Enrollment Period.

There appears to be the possibility for an INDIVIDUAL to make a request for a Special Enrollment Period. AETNA’s letter regarding Endeavor’s exit from the network includes this statement toward the end of the document: “If this change in our network impacts you, you can call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) to ask for a special enrollment period to change plans and for help finding other coverage. Tell them you got this notice saying that your facility is leaving your network.”

But that statement in It doesn’t specify what type of Special Enrollment Period it’s talking about, so it could just be the right to switch Advantage plans outside of the annual open enrollment period and not a special enrollment for a Supplement Plan.

And that is where my comparison of these two situations will end. That may leave you with more questions than answers. Studying this question reminded me just how complicated Medicare is. There are so many rules, so many details, so many exceptions, etc. But I hope that this post gave you a bit more understanding of what’s a stake if you get a letter like this, notifying you that your provider is leaving your plan’s network.

If you want to dig in further, I encourage you to get a cup of coffee (or hot chocolate, if like me, you’re not a coffee drinker) and spend a bit of time with this document. It’s actually the most complete thing I found about guaranteed issue special enrollment periods for Medicare Supplement Plans when your provider network changes. It’s a Q&A where the Federal CMS office answered questions posed by the NAIC (National Association of Insurance Commissioners). It’s not light reading, but if you still have questions, this might be the place where you find the answers.

Here’s the official description of the document:

The FAQ below summarizes CMS’ responses from discussions with NAIC in November 2024 pertaining to a significant change in a Medicare Advantage provider network, relevant special election periods and associated Medigap guaranteed issuance rights for affected beneficiaries.

Download the PDF directly at https://www.cms.gov/files/document/naic-faq-12-17-2024.pdf or go to https://www.cms.gov/medicare/health-drug-plans/medigap and scroll to the Downloads section bottom of the page; click on NAIC FAQ 12-17-2024 (PDF).

Coming Next

Next week, I will show you how to use the Plan Compare tool on the Medicare website. I had intended to write that this week, but the issue of providers leaving Advantage networks seemed to be more pressing right now.

Thanks for leaving a comment. The name you enter will be visible to the public alongside your comment.