Get Ready to Compare Medicare Plans

You probably compared your options when you first signed up for Medicare. If you went the Medicare Advantage route, you compared Advantage plans. If you went the traditional Medicare route, you compared Part D prescription plans and also Medigap plans. The Medigap comparison is pretty much a one-time thing. But for Advantage and Part D, it’s extremely important that you compare plans each and every year during the Open Enrollment Period from October 15 to Dec. 7.

You might be thinking, I’m satisfied with my policy. Or, I haven’t had any changes to my medications this year, so why should I compare? The answer is, because your plan may have changed! They might have dropped your most expensive prescription from their formulary for next year. Your doctor or your pharmacy might no longer be in-network as of 2027. The premium, deductible, or copay may have changed. And even if your plan didn’t make changes, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t a different one out there that might be an even better fit for you. Plus, comparing often doesn’t take all that long.

If you received a paper copy of the Medicare & You 2027 book, the appendix will have a list of all the Part D and Advantage plans available in your state. It includes information such as premiums, deductibles, copay or co-insurance amounts, etc. Downloaded versions typically do not include that section.

That’s a good overview of the differences between policies, but it isn’t sufficient for making a final decision. For that, you need to compare your total costs based on 1) the prescriptions you take, 2) the pharmacies you use, and 3) for Advantage plans, the main health care providers you use.

You potentially have three different ways to get a comparison that uses that personalized information.

An insurance broker may be limited to showing you only plans that will pay them a commission, or plans that they can sell. This is particularly an issue for Part D plans. Beginning in 2026, most Part D plans stopped paying a commission (TerrySavage.com). That means you’re unlikely to get help from an insurance agent with Part D.

Working with a SHIP volunteer or using Medicare’s Plan-Compare tool assures that your comparison will consider every plan that is available to you. You’ll be certain that you’ve chosen the best one for your situation.

Use the following guide to enter all the info that Medicare (or your SHIP volunteer or insurance broker) will need to do the most accurate comparison for you.

How to Enter Your Info Into Medicare’s Plan-Compare Tool

To get accurate projections of how much you will pay under each Part D or Advantage plan choice, the Plan-Compare tool needs to know three things: what prescriptions you take, which pharmacies you are willing to use, and (for Advantage plans) who are your main health care providers. Follow the steps below to add that information.

From any page on the Medicare.gov website, click the Log In icon in the upper right hand corner.

You will see several log-in/create account options on the next screen:

If you have already created a log in for your account, choose the tool you used to create your log in. If you created your account some time ago, you probably used Medicare.gov.

To create your Medicare account, choose any of these options.

Once you have signed in, click on your name in the upper right area of the heading to open the drop-down menu. To start entering your prescriptions, providers, or pharmacies, choose one of those menu items. We’ll start with prescriptions in this example.

You can quickly add your prescriptions by selecting Add recently filled drugs. Prescriptions you filled through either a Part D or Advantage Plan should appear on that list. Just click the prescriptions that you still take.

If your drug history is not available, manually enter each prescription that you take. Doing this while logged in to your account means that info will be saved, and that will save you lots of time when you want to run a new comparison or re-check something.

To get accurate results about your costs, carefully select the correct dosage and form for each prescription. For example, 50 mg vs 100 mg, extended release; tablet vs solution, etc.

Once your click that you’re Done entering prescriptions, you’ll be asked to select pharmacies you’re willing to use.

As you select pharmacies (up to 5), you’ll see them listed at the bottom of your screen.

The next step is adding the health care providers you use regularly. You can skip this step if you have original Medicare and only need to compare Part D plans.

And now, you’re ready to compare plans with the confidence that the projected costs you see will accurately reflect your situation.

This is where we will pick up in the next two blog posts, with step-by-step guides similar to this post, that will walk you through comparing Part D and Medicare Advantage plans.

Thanks for leaving a comment. The name you enter will be visible to the public alongside your comment.